Data Exfiltration: Recognizing Threats and Implementing Solutions

Introduction to Data Exfiltration

In an increasingly digital world, the security of data has become paramount. Cybercriminals and malicious actors are constantly evolving their tactics to exploit vulnerabilities and gain unauthorized access to sensitive information. One of the most concerning threats in this realm is data exfiltration. But what exactly is data exfiltration, and why should we be vigilant about it?

What is Data Exfiltration?

Data exfiltration refers to the unauthorized transfer of data from a computer or network to an external destination. This can involve anything from personal information and financial records to proprietary business data and classified government documents. Unlike data breaches, which might involve the destruction or alteration of data, data exfiltration specifically focuses on the theft of information.

The Growing Threat Landscape

The digital transformation has brought about a vast array of interconnected devices and systems, creating numerous entry points for potential attacks. As organizations increasingly rely on digital solutions, the volume of data being generated, stored, and transmitted has skyrocketed. This makes the task of securing data more challenging and complex, providing ample opportunities for cybercriminals to exploit.

Why is Data Exfiltration Alarming?

The consequences of data exfiltration can be devastating. For businesses, it can result in significant financial losses, legal repercussions, and a tarnished reputation. For individuals, it can lead to identity theft, financial fraud, and a loss of privacy. Governments and public institutions are not immune either; data exfiltration can compromise national security and public safety.

The Anatomy of a Data Exfiltration Attack

To effectively protect against data exfiltration, it's essential to understand how these attacks typically unfold. Generally, a data exfiltration attack involves several stages:

• Infiltration: The attacker gains unauthorized access to the target system or network.
• Establishing Persistence: The attacker ensures continued access by installing backdoors or other malicious tools.
• Data Discovery and Collection: The attacker identifies and gathers the valuable data.
• Exfiltration: The attacker transfers the collected data to an external location.

Each stage involves sophisticated techniques and tools, making detection and prevention challenging.

Real-World Implications

Real-world incidents of data exfiltration underscore the severity of the threat. For instance, the 2017 Equifax breach saw the personal information of over 147 million Americans exfiltrated due to a vulnerability in a web application. Similarly, the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) breach in 2015 resulted in the exfiltration of sensitive data of over 21 million individuals, highlighting the potential for nation-state actors to engage in such activities for espionage purposes.

The Importance of Vigilance

Given the potential damage that data exfiltration can cause, organizations and individuals alike must remain vigilant. This involves implementing robust cybersecurity measures, staying informed about the latest threats, and fostering a culture of security awareness.

Data exfiltration is a cunning and ever-evolving threat, demanding more than just awareness—it requires a vigilant and proactive defense strategy. While recognizing the importance of securing data is crucial, understanding the factors that contribute to data exfiltration is equally vital. By identifying these key elements, we can effectively implement measures to protect ourselves and our organizations from this insidious risk. Let's explore the primary factors that make data exfiltration possible and how to mitigate them.

The Silent Thieves: Key Factors Behind Data Exfiltration

Data exfiltration isn't just a buzzword; it's a silent, persistent threat that can cripple organizations if left unchecked. Understanding the key factors that contribute to unauthorized data transfers is essential for building robust defenses. Let's delve into the elements that make data exfiltration possible and how you can protect against them.

Human Error

Human error remains one of the most significant factors in data exfiltration. Even the most robust security systems can be undermined by simple mistakes made by employees. For instance, an employee might accidentally send sensitive information to the wrong email address, or fall victim to a phishing attack that compromises their login credentials.

Regular training and awareness programs are essential to minimize human error. Employees should be educated on the importance of data security, how to recognize phishing attempts, and the best practices for handling sensitive information.

Insider Threats

While external hackers often grab headlines, insider threats can be just as dangerous. Disgruntled employees, contractors, or even well-meaning staff who fall victim to social engineering can facilitate data exfiltration. Insiders typically have legitimate access to sensitive information, making their activities harder to detect.

Implementing strict access controls and monitoring user behavior can help mitigate insider threats. The principle of least privilege should be enforced, ensuring that users only have access to the data necessary for their roles.

Weak Access Controls

Weak access controls are akin to leaving the gates of a fortress wide open. If access controls are not stringent, unauthorized individuals can easily gain access to sensitive data. This can be due to poor password policies, lack of multi-factor authentication (MFA), or insufficient monitoring of access logs.

SearchInform provides you with quick and accurate data at rest.
Its discovery entails:

Easily make management decisions when all calculated data is one step away

Find solutions quicker and increase productivity thanks to data visibility

Don`t be occupied with time-consuming searches and minimize the human factor, reducing the number of mistakes when data is processed manually

Keep your data storage automated

Learn more

Organizations should enforce strong access control measures, including complex password requirements and MFA. Regular audits of access logs can also help identify any unauthorized access attempts.

Outdated Software and Systems

Running outdated software and systems is like using a rusty lock on a high-security vault. Cybercriminals often exploit known vulnerabilities in outdated software to gain unauthorized access to networks and exfiltrate data.

Regular software updates and patch management are critical to closing these vulnerabilities. Organizations should ensure that all systems, applications, and devices are kept up-to-date with the latest security patches.

Lack of Encryption

Encryption is a cornerstone of data security. Without encryption, sensitive data can be easily intercepted and read by unauthorized individuals. Data should be encrypted both at rest and in transit to ensure its protection.

Implementing robust encryption protocols can significantly reduce the risk of data exfiltration. Even if attackers manage to intercept encrypted data, they will not be able to read or use it without the decryption key.

Insufficient Network Segmentation

Imagine having all your valuables in one easily accessible room; insufficient network segmentation creates a similar risk. When networks are not properly segmented, attackers who gain access to one part of the network can easily move laterally to access sensitive data.

Network segmentation involves dividing the network into smaller, isolated segments, each with its own security controls. This limits the movement of attackers within the network and helps contain breaches.

Inadequate Monitoring and Detection

Without proper monitoring and detection mechanisms, data exfiltration can go unnoticed for extended periods. Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) often involve prolonged and stealthy operations, making continuous monitoring essential.

Implementing tools such as Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS), Intrusion Prevention Systems (IPS), and Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) systems can help detect suspicious activities and potential exfiltration attempts in real-time.

Poor Endpoint Security

Endpoints such as laptops, smartphones, and other devices are often the weakest links in the security chain. Poor endpoint security can provide attackers with a gateway to the network, facilitating data exfiltration.

Deploying Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solutions can enhance endpoint security. EDR tools provide real-time monitoring and analysis of endpoint activities, enabling rapid detection and response to threats.

Cloud Security Risks

The increasing adoption of cloud services introduces new security challenges. Misconfigured cloud settings, inadequate access controls, and vulnerabilities in cloud applications can all contribute to data exfiltration.

Organizations must implement strong security measures for cloud environments, including encryption, access controls, and continuous monitoring. Regular reviews and updates of cloud security policies are essential to address evolving threats.

Third-Party Risks

Third-party vendors and partners can introduce additional risks. If third-party systems are compromised, attackers can use them as a stepping stone to access the organization's network and exfiltrate data.

Conducting thorough security assessments of third-party vendors and establishing strong security agreements can help mitigate these risks. Continuous monitoring of third-party activities is also crucial to ensure compliance with security standards.

Data exfiltration is a multifaceted threat that demands more than just a superficial understanding. To effectively combat this menace, organizations must delve into the myriad factors that contribute to unauthorized data transfers, such as human error, insider threats, weak access controls, outdated software, and insufficient encryption. With these complexities in mind, implementing comprehensive security measures becomes imperative. In an ever-evolving threat landscape, staying informed and proactive is crucial for detecting data exfiltration attempts and safeguarding sensitive information. Let's explore the essential techniques that form the first line of defense against this silent predator.

Data Exfiltration Detection

Detecting data exfiltration is akin to finding a needle in a haystack. In the vast sea of network traffic and system activities, identifying unauthorized data transfers requires a keen eye and advanced techniques. The sophisticated methods used by cybercriminals make detection challenging but not impossible. Let's explore some of the most effective detection techniques that can help organizations safeguard their sensitive information.

Network Traffic Analysis

Imagine trying to spot a single drop of dye in an ocean; that's what network traffic analysis aims to do. Monitoring network traffic for unusual patterns or anomalies can be a powerful tool in detecting data exfiltration. By examining the flow of data packets, organizations can identify red flags that indicate potential exfiltration attempts.

Tools like Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) and Intrusion Prevention Systems (IPS) play a crucial role here. These systems analyze incoming and outgoing traffic, looking for anomalies that deviate from normal patterns. For instance, a sudden spike in data transfer to an external IP address might indicate unauthorized data exfiltration.

Behavioral Analytics

Behavioral analytics takes detection a step further by leveraging the power of machine learning and artificial intelligence. By creating a baseline of normal user and system behavior, these technologies can identify deviations that signal potential exfiltration activities.

Consider how you might notice a friend's unusual behavior; behavioral analytics works similarly. For example, if an employee typically accesses certain files during office hours but suddenly starts transferring large volumes of data late at night, behavioral analytics can flag this as suspicious. This early warning system helps organizations detect and respond to threats before significant damage occurs.

Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR)

Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solutions offer real-time monitoring and analysis of activities on individual devices. Think of EDR as a security guard stationed at every endpoint, constantly watching for suspicious behavior.

EDR tools can detect and respond to a wide range of threats, from malware infections to unauthorized data transfers. By providing visibility into endpoint activities, these solutions enable rapid detection and response to suspicious activities, thereby mitigating risks before they escalate.

Data Loss Prevention (DLP)

Data Loss Prevention (DLP) technologies are like digital guardians, keeping a close eye on sensitive data and ensuring it doesn't leave the organization's boundaries. DLP solutions monitor and control data transfers based on predefined policies, preventing unauthorized exfiltration.

For example, a DLP system might flag an attempt to email a confidential document to an external address. By enforcing data protection policies, DLP technologies help organizations prevent data exfiltration and comply with regulatory requirements.

Anomaly Detection Systems

Anomaly detection systems are designed to spot unusual patterns and behaviors that deviate from the norm. These systems use advanced algorithms to analyze network and system activities, identifying anomalies that could indicate data exfiltration.

Imagine how a metal detector finds hidden objects; anomaly detection systems work similarly. For instance, if a user suddenly starts accessing large volumes of data they don't typically use, the system can flag this as suspicious. By identifying anomalies early, organizations can take swift action to prevent data exfiltration.

User and Entity Behavior Analytics (UEBA)

User and Entity Behavior Analytics (UEBA) focuses on monitoring the behavior of users and entities within the network. By analyzing behavior patterns, UEBA solutions can identify deviations that indicate potential exfiltration activities.

Consider how you might notice if someone starts acting out of character; UEBA works on a similar principle. For example, if a user who typically accesses marketing files suddenly starts downloading financial reports, UEBA can flag this as suspicious. This helps organizations detect insider threats and prevent data exfiltration.

Real-World Application

To illustrate the effectiveness of these detection techniques, consider the 2013 Target breach. Network traffic analysis and anomaly detection could have identified the unusual data transfers to external servers. Similarly, behavioral analytics might have flagged the unauthorized access patterns, allowing for a quicker response to the threat.

Detecting data exfiltration is only half the battle; preventing it is where the real challenge lies. While advanced technologies and vigilant monitoring—such as network traffic analysis, behavioral analytics, EDR, DLP, anomaly detection systems, and UEBA—can significantly enhance our ability to detect and respond to potential threats, a proactive approach to prevention is essential. In the ever-evolving landscape of cyber threats, staying ahead of malicious actors requires a comprehensive strategy that not only identifies threats but also implements robust measures to prevent data exfiltration and protect sensitive information. Let's explore the key prevention strategies that can fortify our defenses against this insidious risk.

Data Exfiltration Prevention Strategies

Data exfiltration is a sophisticated and ever-evolving threat that demands a vigilant and proactive defense strategy. While detection methods are crucial, prevention is the best cure. By implementing a range of effective prevention strategies, organizations can significantly reduce the risk of unauthorized data transfers. Let's delve into some of the most impactful prevention techniques.

How to protect confidential documents from unwanted access and operations

Analyse information security risks which appear when documents stay within the corporate perimeter

Download

Regular Software Updates

Keeping your software up-to-date is like fortifying a castle with the latest defenses. Ensuring that all software and systems are current with the latest security patches can close vulnerabilities that attackers might exploit. Outdated software often contains known vulnerabilities that can be easily targeted by cybercriminals. Regular updates and patch management are essential to maintaining a secure environment.

Strong Access Controls

Strong access controls are the locks and keys to your digital kingdom. Implementing strict access controls and adhering to the principle of least privilege ensures that users only have access to the data necessary for their roles. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds an extra layer of security, making unauthorized access more difficult. By limiting access to sensitive data, organizations can reduce the risk of insider threats and unauthorized data exfiltration.

Data Encryption

Data encryption is a must-have in today’s digital age. Encrypting sensitive data both at rest and in transit ensures that even if attackers manage to steal information, they cannot easily read or use it. Encryption transforms data into an unreadable format, which can only be deciphered with the appropriate decryption key. This adds a robust layer of security, protecting data from unauthorized access and exfiltration.

Employee Training

Educating your workforce is like training an army; well-informed employees are one of the best defenses against cyber threats. Regular training sessions on the risks of phishing and social engineering, along with promoting good cybersecurity practices, can significantly reduce the risk of data exfiltration. Employees should be trained to recognize suspicious emails, avoid clicking on unknown links, and report any unusual activities. A well-informed workforce can act as the first line of defense against cyber threats.

Network Segmentation

Think of network segmentation as creating compartments in a ship to prevent it from sinking. Dividing a network into segments can limit the spread of an attack and make it more difficult for attackers to access sensitive data. Each segment can have its own security controls, further enhancing protection. By isolating critical systems and sensitive data, organizations can minimize the impact of a potential breach and contain threats more effectively.

Data Loss Prevention (DLP) Technologies

Data Loss Prevention (DLP) technologies are like digital guardians, keeping a close eye on sensitive data and ensuring it doesn't leave the organization's boundaries. DLP solutions monitor and control data transfers based on predefined policies, preventing unauthorized exfiltration. For example, a DLP system might flag an attempt to email a confidential document to an external address. By enforcing data protection policies, DLP technologies help organizations prevent data exfiltration and comply with regulatory requirements.

Endpoint Protection

Think of endpoint protection as a security guard stationed at every device. Endpoint protection solutions offer real-time monitoring and analysis of activities on individual devices. By providing visibility into endpoint activities, these solutions enable rapid detection and response to suspicious activities, thereby mitigating risks before they escalate. Endpoint protection can include antivirus software, firewalls, and advanced threat detection capabilities.

Monitoring and Anomaly Detection

Imagine how a metal detector finds hidden objects; monitoring and anomaly detection systems work similarly. These systems use advanced algorithms to analyze network and system activities, identifying anomalies that could indicate data exfiltration. For instance, if a user suddenly starts accessing large volumes of data they don't typically use, the system can flag this as suspicious. By identifying anomalies early, organizations can take swift action to prevent data exfiltration.

Cloud Security Measures

With the increasing use of cloud services, securing cloud environments has become paramount. Implementing strong security measures for cloud storage and applications can prevent unauthorized data exfiltration. This includes using encryption, access controls, and monitoring tools specifically designed for cloud environments. Regularly reviewing and updating cloud security policies ensures that they remain effective against evolving threats.

Incident Response Planning

Even with the best preventive measures, breaches can still happen. Having a robust incident response plan is crucial for minimizing damage and recovering from an attack. Key components of an effective incident response plan include establishing and training an incident response team, defining roles and responsibilities, and setting up communication protocols. Quick identification, containment, and eradication of threats, followed by recovery and post-incident analysis, can help organizations bounce back from data exfiltration attempts.

Preventing data exfiltration demands a comprehensive, multi-faceted approach. Organizations must implement regular software updates, strong access controls, data encryption, employee training, network segmentation, DLP technologies, endpoint protection, monitoring and anomaly detection, cloud security measures, and robust incident response planning. However, even with these defenses in place, regulatory compliance plays a pivotal role in ensuring data security. Adhering to regulatory frameworks not only helps mitigate the risk of unauthorized data transfers but also shields organizations from legal and financial repercussions. Let’s explore the critical role of regulatory compliance in protecting sensitive information from data exfiltration.

Regulatory Compliance for Data Exfiltration

In the realm of cybersecurity, regulatory compliance is more than just a bureaucratic hurdle; it is a critical aspect of safeguarding sensitive information. As data breaches and exfiltration incidents continue to rise, governments worldwide have introduced stringent regulations to protect personal and organizational data. By adhering to these regulations, organizations can not only avoid hefty fines but also enhance their overall security posture. Let's dive into the importance of regulatory compliance for data exfiltration and explore some key frameworks.

The Imperative of Regulatory Compliance

Ignoring regulatory compliance is like playing with fire. The consequences of non-compliance can be severe, including legal repercussions, financial penalties, and irreparable damage to an organization's reputation. Compliance frameworks are designed to ensure that organizations implement necessary security measures to protect sensitive data from unauthorized access and exfiltration.

General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

The GDPR has set a high bar for data protection. Enforced in the European Union, the GDPR mandates strict guidelines for the collection, storage, and transfer of personal data. Organizations must implement robust security measures to prevent data breaches and exfiltration. Failure to comply can result in fines of up to 4% of the annual global turnover or €20 million, whichever is higher.

One of the key aspects of GDPR is the requirement for organizations to report data breaches within 72 hours. This necessitates having a well-defined incident response plan in place, ensuring that any potential data exfiltration is quickly identified and addressed.

Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)

When it comes to healthcare, data protection is paramount. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) sets national standards for the protection of electronic health information in the United States. Covered entities, such as healthcare providers and insurers, must implement stringent security measures to protect patient data from unauthorized access and exfiltration.

HIPAA compliance involves regular risk assessments, employee training, and the implementation of technical safeguards such as encryption and access controls. Violations can lead to significant penalties, including fines and potential criminal charges.

California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)

California has taken a strong stance on data privacy with the introduction of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). This regulation grants California residents extensive rights over their personal data, including the right to know what data is being collected and the right to request its deletion.

Organizations must implement measures to prevent unauthorized data exfiltration and ensure that consumer data is handled transparently and securely. Non-compliance can result in fines of up to $7,500 per violation, making it imperative for businesses to adhere to CCPA guidelines.

Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)

For businesses handling payment card information, PCI DSS compliance is non-negotiable. This set of security standards is designed to protect cardholder data from breaches and exfiltration. Organizations must implement a range of security measures, including encryption, access controls, and regular security testing.

Why to choose MSS by SearchInform

Access to cutting-edge solutions with minimum financial costs

No need to find and pay for specialists with rare competencies

A protection that can be arranged ASAP

Ability to increase security even without an expertise in house

The ability to obtain an audit or a day-by-day support

Learn more

Non-compliance with PCI DSS can result in severe consequences, including fines, increased transaction fees, and even the loss of the ability to process credit card payments. Compliance ensures not only the security of cardholder data but also the trust of customers.

The Role of Compliance Officers

Compliance officers are the unsung heroes of data protection. These professionals are responsible for ensuring that an organization adheres to all relevant regulations and implements necessary security measures. They conduct regular audits, provide training, and develop policies to mitigate the risk of data exfiltration.

Developing a Compliance Strategy

A well-defined compliance strategy is essential for protecting sensitive data. Organizations must conduct regular risk assessments to identify potential vulnerabilities and implement appropriate safeguards. Employee training programs should be established to ensure that all staff members are aware of regulatory requirements and best practices for data protection.

Moreover, organizations should invest in advanced security technologies such as Data Loss Prevention (DLP) systems, encryption, and Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solutions. These tools can help detect and prevent data exfiltration, ensuring that compliance requirements are met.

Real-World Implications

The consequences of non-compliance can be seen in various high-profile data breaches. For instance, the 2018 British Airways breach resulted in a £20 million fine under GDPR regulations. The breach exposed the personal data of over 400,000 customers, highlighting the importance of adhering to regulatory requirements.

Regulatory compliance is a cornerstone of effective data protection. By adhering to frameworks such as GDPR, HIPAA, CCPA, and PCI DSS, organizations can mitigate the risk of data exfiltration and ensure the security of sensitive information. A proactive approach to compliance, involving regular risk assessments, employee training, and the implementation of advanced security technologies, is essential for maintaining robust cybersecurity defenses in an ever-evolving threat landscape.

Fortify Your Defenses: How SearchInform Solutions Combat Data Exfiltration

Data exfiltration poses a significant threat to organizations, but SearchInform offers a range of solutions designed to combat various methods of unauthorized data transfers. Let’s explore the benefits of SearchInform solutions for each type of data exfiltration.

Threat: Manual Data Exfiltration

Solution: Insider Threats and Physical Access

Insider threats and physical access vulnerabilities can be a major concern for organizations. SearchInform solutions provide robust monitoring and control mechanisms to mitigate these risks. Monitoring user activity is crucial for detecting suspicious behavior. SearchInform allows organizations to track actions such as file access and transfers in real-time. This makes it easier to identify any unusual patterns that may indicate malicious intent or potential data exfiltration.

In addition to monitoring, controlling USB and peripheral devices is essential. SearchInform solutions enable organizations to restrict the use of external storage devices and monitor data transfers. This prevents unauthorized copying of sensitive information. Furthermore, employee behavior analysis is another powerful tool. By identifying unusual patterns or actions, organizations can detect potential insider threats before they escalate.

Threat: Automated Data Exfiltration

Solution: Real-Time Threat Detection and Behavioral Analytics

Automated data exfiltration often involves sophisticated techniques. SearchInform solutions offer advanced detection and prevention capabilities to counter these threats. Real-time threat detection is a key feature, allowing organizations to identify and neutralize unauthorized data transfers by monitoring network traffic and endpoint activities. By quickly spotting and responding to potential threats, SearchInform helps to safeguard sensitive information.

Behavioral analytics is another powerful tool in combating automated data exfiltration. Utilizing machine learning, SearchInform can detect deviations from normal user and system behavior. This helps in flagging potential automated exfiltration attempts. Additionally, deploying advanced firewall protection can block malicious traffic and prevent unauthorized data transfers. These combined measures create a robust defense against automated data exfiltration.

Threat: Network-Based Data Exfiltration

Solution: Email, HTTP/HTTPS, and FTP/SFTP Traffic

Network-based exfiltration methods can be particularly challenging to detect. However, SearchInform’s solutions enhance network security through various means. Network traffic analysis is a powerful tool that allows organizations to monitor and analyze network traffic. By identifying unusual patterns or anomalies, potential data exfiltration can be detected early.

Data Loss Prevention (DLP) is another critical component. Implementing DLP policies helps control and monitor data transfers, ensuring that sensitive information does not leave the organization via email or other protocols. Encryption monitoring is also vital. Ensuring that data transfers over HTTP/HTTPS and FTP/SFTP are secure and compliant with encryption standards adds an extra layer of protection. Together, these measures create a formidable defense against network-based data exfiltration.

Threat: Cloud-Based Data Exfiltration

Solution: Cloud Storage Services and Applications

With the increasing reliance on cloud services, securing cloud environments is paramount. SearchInform solutions provide comprehensive cloud security measures. Cloud activity monitoring is essential for tracking and analyzing user activities in cloud environments. This helps in detecting unauthorized access and data transfers.

Implementing stringent access controls is another key measure. Ensuring that only authorized users can access and transfer sensitive data in the cloud minimizes the risk of unauthorized exfiltration. Regular compliance auditing is also crucial. By auditing cloud security settings and access logs, organizations can ensure compliance with regulatory requirements and internal policies. These combined measures provide robust protection against cloud-based data exfiltration.

Threat: Covert Channels

Solution: Timing Channels

Timing analysis is another powerful tool. By analyzing network and system event timings, SearchInform can identify patterns that may indicate the presence of timing channels. Advanced threat detection further enhances the ability to detect and flag covert data exfiltration methods. These combined measures create a robust defense against covert channels.

SearchInform solutions offer a comprehensive suite of tools designed to combat various types of data exfiltration. From manual methods and insider threats to automated malware and covert channels, SearchInform provides robust monitoring, detection, and prevention capabilities. By leveraging these solutions, organizations can enhance their security posture, protect sensitive information, and mitigate the risk of unauthorized data transfers in an ever-evolving threat landscape. Whether it's real-time threat detection, behavioral analytics, or advanced firewall protection, SearchInform has the tools needed to stay ahead of cyber threats.